OliviaPierson.org - Free Thought Advocate
  • Book: Western Values Defended
  • Blog
  • About & Contact

This website uses marketing and tracking technologies. Opting out of this will opt you out of all cookies, except for those needed to run the website. Note that some products may not work as well without tracking cookies.

Opt Out of Cookies

The Tragic Worldview Versus the Therapeutic

11/6/2020

4 Comments

 
Picture
St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre of the Huguenots 1572. Paris. By Francois Dubois
By Olivia Pierson
​First published on Insight@theBFD 4/06/2020

When it comes to democracy, both ancient and modern, there are forces which compete at its heart serving as a moral tension which give the whole system a certain vigour, until it unravels either through mob-tyranny or outright dictatorship.  

In ancient Athens, arguments were had over equality versus freedom, an old left/right divide between those who believed that people were not equal and then those who believed that they could be made equal if human nature could just be overridden a little – or a lot.

The progressive view still insists today that equality is more important than freedom, therefore welcomes, or at least tolerates, state intrusion into the lives and livelihoods of citizens to see wealth redistributed “more equally.”

The conservative view resents this meddling and places a premium on individual freedom, recognising (occasionally) that if individual rights can be overridden for the sake of the wellbeing of others, where does the sacrifice end?

Progressives on both the Left and Right are addicted to societal meddling – and there really is no end to it. All things can be fixed, remedied or improved in their view. Utopia is always just one more government programme away (or execution away in the case of communist countries) from being ushered in, if only those other bastards would stop being so myopically selfish and go along with it all unquestioningly. 

Conservatives tend to see human nature as more immutable across time. There are limits which are informed by reality as to what humans can achieve, or not, and above all, humans are fallible creatures whose mistakes can often define them well beyond a single lifespan. Conservatives want to be pretty much left alone to do their best for themselves and their families and afford other people the same courtesy to do likewise. Folks must stand or fall, succeed or fail, live or die, on their own merits, talents, achievements and plans. There it is. 

Early Western thought fully absorbed both these world views – the Greek tragic outlook and the Judaeo-Christian therapeutic view.  This was the marriage of the ideas of Athens and Jerusalem, officiated in the bosom of the Roman Empire where they eventually bonded in jurisprudence. 

By the time that the Renaissance bloomed in Europe circa 1500, reviving an interest in Greco-Roman literature and art, morality and metaphysical thought expressed human nature at its most heroic, fateful, grotesque, tragic and redemptive through the insightful pen of William Shakespeare – Henry V, Romeo and Juliette, The Tempest, MacBeth, King Lear, Richard III and Antony and Cleopatra. 

Politically, Elizabeth I transformed her insignificant island nation into something of a European super-power during her long 44-year reign, which was her sealed fate to inherit by virtue of nothing other than her bloodline as King Henry VIII's daughter. Yet her reign saw little peace as the Reformation raged on, a return to the “one true church of Rome” never about to happen on her faithful Protestant watch. After her death, many of her subjects fled England forever to escape sectarian violence, landing on Virginia’s shores in the New World – redemptive namesakes if ever there were. 

The Constitution of the Founding Fathers of America some 150 years later was the handiwork of Puritan culture being tempered and prescribed by the intellectual currents of the European Enlightenment, at the same time as being brought down to its base level of Original Sin by locking the institution of black slavery well within the parchment and ink of the document itself. 

I was interested this afternoon to listen to an excellent interview with George Friedman on the Leighton Smith Podcast which touched on these very topics I’d been engaged with for the last few days.
 
There is no sweeping remedy for the black vs white dilemma which America regularly falls prey to, according to Friedman, since it’s in the nation’s DNA from its inception and often over-boils. 
 
Rather than be remedied across the board in some therapeutic manner, the way ahead after these recent tumultuous riots (orchestrated by ANTIFA thugs), is doing what America has always had to do – seek justice through the rule of law and live with the results. Not every problem has a solution but in this case, George Floyd’s killer will go to trial and face justice. 

We live within the confines of human nature and reality, not Utopia.  An idea, let alone a massive nation, does not have to be perfect to be considered good.
 
In his interview with Smith, Friedman underscored an important point: the whole of Europe, Africa and Arabia practised slavery, in fact America had acquired the practice from the Dutch, yet all the European nations rid themselves of it without the need for a massive civil war. The potent flashpoint of the “sin” being “unforgivable” in America exists in the Framers of the Constitution knowing slavery was evil, yet writing it into the laws of the Republic despite claiming to believe that “all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights.”

The fact that the Framers’ descendants are still being held responsible for the consequences of that sin, despite heroes like Lincoln seeking countermeasures through virtue, through war and the resulting Thirteenth Amendment, even losing his own life for his efforts, to say nothing of the many Northern Americans who fought on the side of the Union – and everything that has transpired since to give the descendants of slaves equality and freedom – smacks of a Greek tragedy of epic proportion.
 
The age old tension between equality and freedom still dogs us 2300 years after the ancient Greek versions of democracy, but it has to be said that it dogs us now mostly because it’s a topic which gets exacerbated by the aggressive pedlars of victimology who push for more and more state controls, including financial dependencies and monetary reparations, which are ongoing forms of permanent looting. 

It is not anyone’s place to feel guilty for what their distant ancestors did or didn’t do. Do Europeans, some of whose descendants like myself now live in NZ, demand reparations with a straight face from the Vatican over the massacres of the French Huguenots in the 16th Century? 


If you enjoyed this article, please buy my book "Western Values Defended: A Primer"

​
 

4 Comments
Wayne Greer
10/6/2020 10:13:35 pm

Very good indeed, Olivia.
I too just listened to the Friedman discussion with Leighton Smith.
It was quite revealing when Friedman Accused Smith of being a liberal, because he was suggesting That the black white problem in the USA could and should be fixed. In fact, it is what it is as a Friedman says.
The problem now though, is extreme actors like Antifa who pour fuel on simmering fires. Then chaos ensues. Which is those bad actors want, of course. Anarchy is their game. NWO to follow.

Reply
Pb
14/6/2020 03:33:58 am

Racism is a sin, common to all men. I have heard shocking racism from all sorts of people, black, white, blue. You can’t legislate away sin. Nor can you bomb it. Protests seem the wrong approach. Particularly when the devolve to violence, theft and murder. All peoples were slaves. And slavers. These riots are deliberate violence pushed by revolutionaries. Media culpable. Bring back the moral law.

Reply
Olivia
14/6/2020 03:48:00 pm

Howie,

I removed your comment because it said Not For Publication - I’m assuming you wanted me to read it but not have it on the board?
If you want me to put it back up, let me know. They automatically go up without any help from me.

Anyway, I hadn’t seen the Diana West thing - amazing. I’m even more worried now. Juntas in the making. Wannabe Napoleons.

Reply
Howie
14/6/2020 11:56:57 pm

Olivia...I leave it to your discretion. It was a different topic thus the heading. I just wanted to impart the info to you about Diana. Hopefully, Patton is shooting off his pearl-handed pistols in the psychological awareness of DJT.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Trump’s 2018 Executive Order on Foreign Interference in an Election
    AG Bill Barr’s Betrayal
    Criminalising Hate Speech - an Affront to Our Natural Liberties
    Exposing Election Fraud - an Exercise in Moral Courage
    Sidney powell, the Kraken and the CIA
    The Kafkaesque Culture Setting Flicks ON!
    Throwing Light on the Gas-lighters
    And Right on Cue, the Democrats Have Cheated
    It’s Trump or a Green Government Commie Take-over
    The New York Times Still Supports Scurrilous Journalists
    The First U.S. Election Debate 2020 - Trump Won
    Mothers Matter: A Worthy Charity
    The Historic Abraham Accords
    The “Bleach" Lie About Trump was Pure Fake News
    Obama’s Race-War Rhetoric Versus Trump’s Historic Achievements for Blacks
    Virginia Fallon and More Stuff(ed) Journalism
    NZ Institutions Must Disavow Their Support for Black Lives Matter
    Why All the Panic Porn When Covid Cures Exist?
    Lockdowns Are Destructive and Wrong
    Lockdowns Don’t Work - Ask Belgium
    As Surely as Night Follows Day, the Democrats Will Try to Cheat
    Liberals Go After Tucker Carlson, Again
    Now That It’s Up to Judith
    This Fragile Thing Called Liberty
    Slurs of racism and atheism
    A Cultivated Woman, Who Can Find?
    Methinks Thou Dost Protest Too Much
    Race Victim Business Booms Even During Covid
    The Tragic Worldview Versus the Therapeutic
    Can a Dictatorship Happen in America?
    Dr. Siouxsie Wiles Supports the Worst People in America
    From Prime Minister to Tyrant
    MAGA Hats and Muslimas Downunder
    Obama’s Legacy is Obamagate
    Sleepy Joe or Senile Joe?
    Guest-post: A Lockdown Letter to Government Asserting Non-Consent
    Remember Folks, Altruism Means Sacrifice
    Groupthinker Ghahraman
    Did China Unleash a Bio-Weapon?
    The FBI Exposed yet Again by Inspector General Horowitz
    Live Free or Die; Death is Not the Worst of Evils
    The Bot Shared ‘Round the World
    Sovereign Borders Are Back - Except for Erdogan's
    Postmodernism, not Humanism, Eroded Our Cultural Values
    Rights Based on Natural Law Part Two: According to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights
    Rights Based on Natural Law, Part One: According to John Locke
    Hannah Tamaki is the Victim of Bullying, Not the Bully
    Powerful Documentary: Dear Zachary - A Letter to a Son About His Father
    Observe Labour’s New-Found Silence on Hate Speech Laws
    As Trump says ‘God Bless America!’ Pelosi Rips up the Entire SOTU Speech
    From Peace to Prosperity: Trump’s Middle East Peace Plan
    What Happened to Renaud Camus is Coming to NZ
    The Child Molesters of the Mind Pervert More NZ Children
    Guest Post: Sir Roger Scruton Taught Me Why Beauty Matters, by Dieuwe de Boer
    Iran: Khamenei’s Cock-Ups
    Chernobyl and Other Collectivist Catastrophes
    The Inspector General’s Report Shows FBI Abused its Power
    Terrorism Must Be Met With the Death Penalty
    Goodbye the Plantation: Trump, Blacks & Kanye
    The New Conservative Party NZ
    The Leighton Smith Podcast 43: International Men’s Day and an Interview With Me
    Is Impeachment the Last Gasp of the Democratic Party?
    A Toast to the Death of a Malevolent Monster
    The World is What We Make it
    The Trouble with the Syrian Kurds
    Moore on the “Joker"
    PM Ardern - Unpatriotic Globalist
    Greta, Iran and Impeachment (again): An Outstanding Week of Leftist Autism
    Dear Prime Minister Ardern, About God-Emperor Trump
    Bolton vs the Trump Doctrine - it’s Complicated
    Ignoble Altruism
    Announcing the World’s High Point for 2019 - Guest Post by Lindsay Perigo
    G7 Shows Why Trump is the Leader of the Free World
    The Life of Thomas Paine: Radical Revolutionary
    Another Ecofascist Murder Spree
    No Humour Please, We’re Kiwis
    The Strange Testimony of Robert Mueller the Third
    A Squad of Bunny-boilers
    The Great Unravelling of the Postwar Order
    Danielle McLaughlin - NZ’s Fake-News Writeress in Chief
    Ardern and Peters Call to Appease the Psychopaths of Iran for Oil
    Hey WARF! A Word on Fascism and Islam
    Left-wing Baby Boomers Changed the World - then Failed to Notice!
    The Ongoing United Nations Sex Abuse Scandal
    Parenting Denotes Ownership
    Global Muslim Leaders Conference for NZ: Was Sri Lanka Booked Out?
    Jacinda Ardern: The Woman’s Weekly Prime Minister
    The Woke are a Threat to Rule of Law: Guest Post by Graham Hill
    David Seymour, Leader of the Opposition? Guest post by Dieuwe de Boer
    The Insidious Organising Principle of ‘Equality'
    Strange Cultural Bedfellows
    Sam Harris’ Best Podcast on Jihad: Why We Hate You & why We fight you
    Little Truth Does He Know
    Religion, Beauty & Eternity
    ANZAC Day 2019: The Lost Generation (Reprised)
    Sadder than Fiction, Notre Dame Burns
    The Right-wing of NZ Needs Courage
    Leighton Smith Podcast with Myself & Stephen Franks
    Screwing Over NZ’s Future for Immediate Emotional Gains
    Fascists Hate Free Speech - and They’re Running New Zealand
    Lindsay Perigo on Christchurch: Two Weeks On
    Fair-weather Feminist
    World Citizens’ Pledge: Upholding Free Speech & Non-Violence
    Banning of Manifesto a Step too Far - NZ Free Speech Coalition
    What’s Coming Our Way Courtesy of the United Nations
    Rhetoric Doesn’t Kill People, Violence Does: New Zealand’s Anger, Sorrow & Worry
    Is Western Civilisation Exhausted?
    Let’s Get Real Reporters to Tommy’s Trial, by Ezra Levant
    New Zealand Must be Better than Australia on Milo Yiannopoulos Issue: Press Release by NZ Free Speech Coalition
    The Remarkably Rambunctious Milo Yiannopoulos
    Tommy Robinson Censored Again!
    Victor Davis Hanson: The Worthiest Intellect of our Time
    The Ridiculous Row over Blackface
    Trump Delivers the Antidote to the Toxic Left
    The Left is the Enemy of the Free World
    Casual Racism is Healthy
    Phil Gifford Writes Cam Slater Deserves his Stroke: The Compassionate Left speaks
    Politics & War
    Ardern & Peters Rule in Darkness
    Brexit Won then Stymied, Thanks to Nigel Farage
    A Tale of Two Revolutions
    Reject the UN Global Migration Pact!
    Steve Bannon and The Movement
    Saving Free Speech from Profa, by Lindsay Perigo
    The Trump Trigger
    Letter to Immigration NZ: Asylum for Asia Bibi
    The Murderers Exchanged for Bergdahl Fight on for the Taliban
    The Postwar Hangover
    Schumer and Pelosi: Two Bad Faith Sewer Rats
    Of Truth and Human Decency: to Speak, to Hear. By Graham Hill
    Khashoggi and Middle Eastern Grotesqueries
    Postmodernism, not Humanism, Eroded our Cultural Values
    Heroic & Future Oriented: President Trump's U.N Speech 2018
    How the Enlightenment Ends: by Henry A Kissinger
    Dr. Christine Blasey Ford: An Emotional Cloud of Camouflage
    The #MeToo's Attempted Castration of Kavanaugh
    Casual Remarks about Trump's Assassination now Commonplace
    Obama & Biden: Any Excuse to not Move on
    The Deep State Resistance is Real
    McCain's Brand of Patriotism is Questionable
    An Evening with Douglas Murray & Cornel West: Polarised
    There is no Measure for Hate Speech
    Where are all the Literal Fascists?
    The Angry, Very, Very Angry Hazim Arafeh
    Of Godfathers and Presidents
    Kiwis Just Put Their Money Where Their Mouths Are
    Victor Hugo: the Soul of Politics
    Free Speech Coalition NZ is Launched: Media Release
    Phascist Phil and Islamophascists Ban Stefan and Lauren: by Lindsay Perigo
    The Fault Line Tommy Robinson's Imprisonment Exposes
    Hating Your President More than Loving Your Country
    Letter From Tommy Robinson in Prison
    The Human Rights Commission & Free Speech
    The War on Beauty (guest post by Ed Cline)
    Swamps & Vipers
    Ding, Dong, Devoy Is Gone—but Her Evil Flourishes Everywhere! (Free Tommy Robinson!) by Lindsay Perigo
    The Pathetic Palestinians
    The Bad Deal Iran Never Honoured
    NZ Racism & Unearned Guilt
    For Anzac Day: The Lost Generation
    The Red-line of Chemical Weapons
    Syria: the Makings of a Sustained Foreign Entanglement
    The Atavistic Impulse to Tear Down History
    A World where Men are not Angels
    The Philosophical Side of Politics
    A Couple of Brilliant Battle-axes: Rand and Paglia
    Obama: an Extraordinary Apprising
    The Gift of Colonialism
    Satire Died a Quick Death in New Zealand
    Fottles, Fatwas and Free Speech: Guest Post by Lindsay Perigo
    The Female Matrix - take the Red Pill!
    History is a Harsh Mistress
    America Never was "a Nation of Immigrants"
    Guest Post by Ed Cline: Malice Aforethought, an Exercise in Impotence
    Thank God It Left NZ - Can We Please Have Peterson Instead?
    Jacinda Ardern as Inspiring as Benazir Bhutto?
    Oprah: A Coloured Woman or a Woman?
    Lessons from Lincoln
    Jayda Fransen - Doing the Lord's Work
    Feminist Foreign Policy - Sweden's 'Screwtape' Initiative
    President Trump - One Year In
    NZ Herald Oozes anti-Trump Psychobabble
    Anna Netrebko Graces Auckland
    The Spiritual Experience
    Massey University Spreads Trump Derangement Syndrome
    An Intellectual Debt Owed to cicero
    Bravo President Trump!
    The Problem with Women
    The President's burden
    Guest Post by Jennifer Grossman: Date the Atlas, Not the Shrug
    The West has Brought this upon Itself
    Europe Welcomes Returning isis fighters back home
    We Must Speak Freely - it's Holy Ground!
    climate alarmism is the opiate of the people
    Guest Post - Trump vs The Filth: 100 Days In, Trump is Winning! By Lindsay Perigo
    Marine Le Pen a Nationalist? You Say that like it's a bad thing
    The Assad Regime is Secular, My Foot
    Hager Tryng to Mess with the Big Boys Again. Yawn
    Ayaan Hirsi Ali vs the Muslimas Downunder
    Rape Culture Carping
    New Zealand Lashed by Constant Race Relations Propaganda
    International Women's Whining Day
    New Zealand Media Afflicted with Bad Case of TDS
    Of Giants, Syndromes & the New Zealand Way
    Letter to My Prime Minister, Bill English: Re Murray McCully's Appalling Actions
    2016: The Year of the Bold Iconoclasts
    A Crisis Averted
    On the Eve of the Election, from Downunder: Dear America...
    The Puritans of the Republic Clutch at their Pearls
    Civilization's Precondition - Freedom from restrictions imposed by others
    Guest Post by Edward Cline - Review: Western Values Defended - a Primer
    I, Clinton.
    "Terrorism Has no religion?" - don't be absurd, ms. devoy!
    Feminists, not men, lead the war against women
    Why Trump Deserves to Win the American Election
    The Beautiful Lady in the Middle - Hypatia of Alexandria
    a republic, madam, if you can keep it
    Multiculturalism's treachery
    Heroes of the Enlightenment (Film)
    Religion & State got a Divorce (thank goodness)
    Elizabeth I: High Renaissance Queen
    Why Sneer at Capitalism?
    Unity through Diversity Equals Cultural Death
    What was The Enlightenment?
    stability over insanity in Iraq... yeah, right.

    Post Archives

    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    January 2015
    August 2014

    RSS Feed

    Links to Other Blogs

    The Daily Moff
    TrueblueNZ
    Solopassion
    Edward Cline Blogspot
    Whaleoil
    The Rule of Reason
    Ann Coulter's Blog
    Mark Steyn Online
    Breitbart
    ​
    Not PC Blogspot
  • Book: Western Values Defended
  • Blog
  • About & Contact